Interactionist Theory. comparatively, social interactionist theory takes the perspective that the learners own "personal interpretations of the world based on individual experiences and interactions." (ertmer & newby, 2013, pg 55) determines how the learning is facilitated, where a guiding adult is utilised to provide an interactive experience to encourage cognitive This is why, according to Blumer, behavior is changing, unpredictable, and unique. Unlike first languages, which many theorists argue we have an inbuilt and subconscious ability to speak, learning second languages is more like acquiring any other skill. For this reason, The Self and Political Role is often considered to be a classic study in the Iowa school of Symbolic Interactionism (Carter and Fuller, 2015). There are three theories on how humans acquire language: the Nativist, Learning (Behaviorist), and Interactionist theories. Which of the following are criticisms of a constructivist approach to teaching? Create the most beautiful study materials using our templates. Children cannot yet think logically and still have a very egocentric view of the world. Because all behavior happens on the basis of an individuals own meanings about the world, Blumer believed that observing general behavioral patterns was not conducive to scientific insight (Carter and Fuller, 2015). Vygotsky's (1896-1934) sociocultural theory views learning as a social process. Kuhn, M. H. (1964). Stryker, S. (1980). Cognitive Interactionist Approach. The overwhelming majority of interactions in our daily lives are face-to-face so it makes sense that our primary way of understanding one another is from a second-person perspective rather than from the detached, theoretical, third-person perspective described by TT and ST. Piaget's theory was very influential in the field of language acquisition and helped directly link language learning with intellectual development. The Sensorimotor Stage, The Preoperational Stage, The Concrete Operational Stage, and The Formal Operational Stage. These, combined with personal narratives, provide the background knowledge that allows us to implicitly frame the actions of others in understandable narratives, providing a fallible and revisable sense of what the other is up to. Sometime during the first year of life infants also start to enter into joint attention situations and begin to pay attention to how others act and what they do with objects in everyday contexts, and this also provides a way to understand their intentions and contextualized actions. Their studies often involve observation of one-on-one interactions. Cognitive Interactionist Approach The cognitive interactionist approach views language learning as an individual cognitive effort. False. Gender & society, 1(2), 125-151. var domainroot="www.simplypsychology.org" Create beautiful notes faster than ever before. For e.g. For example, a child may correctly learn the word "gave" (past tense of "give"), and later on use . These relationships, Casino and Thien (2020) argue, can happen both between people and other people in a place and between people and objects in their environment. Vygotsky's theory completely contradicts Jean Piaget's theory of cognitive development. True or False - Piaget believed that children should not have the chance to explore the world by themselves, because it is too dangerous? hasContentIssue true, impact of design and implementation variables on interaction, https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108643689.006, Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. function Gsitesearch(curobj){curobj.q.value="site:"+domainroot+" "+curobj.qfront.value}. ), Action, Gesture and Symbol: The Emergence of Language (pp. The cognitive approach takes an interactionist view of the debate as it argues that our behavior is influenced by learning and experience (nurture), but also by some of our brains' innate capacities as information processors e.g. Annual review of anthropology, 19(1), 453-505. Which of the following are criticisms of the cognitive theory? Constructivists believe that individuals actively construct their knowledge of the world based on their own experiences, interactions, ideas, and previous understandings of the world. The symbolic-interactionists look for patterns of interaction between individuals. Alternatively, when introducing a brand new topic, the teacher should encourage students to draw upon relatable background knowledge. Manage Settings Who created the information process theory? Interactionist Theory meaning. Interactionism theory is also known as symbolic interactionism or interactionist perspective/theory. The social world is therefore constructed by the meanings that individuals attach to events and social interactions, and these symbols are transmitted across the generations through language. Collaborative learning is the idea that conversations with older people can help children both cognitively and linguistically ( Read More Interactionist Long's interaction hypothesis also stresses the importance of comprehensible input . Asking students to reflect on their answers and explain how they came to their conclusions. They believe lessons should be student-oriented. Symbolic interaction theory. To Kuhn, behavior was purposive, socially constructed, coordinated social acts informed by preceding events in the context of projected acts that occur. Social interaction can be studied in a way that emphasizes the interrelatedness of an individuals intention, sense of time, and the ways that they correct their own systems of meanings. The definition of deviance is relative and depends on the culture, time period, and situation. In his book The Language and Thought of the Child (1923), he also stated that a child's language functions in two different ways: During the sensorimotor stage, children's language is very egocentric and they communicate for themselves. Mead GH. The theory recognizes that learning a new language is an active process that involves building upon schemas and utilizing specific learning strategies to enhance comprehension and retain information. Applying the cognitive theory in the classroom involves taking a student-led approach to teaching. Children will also begin to form basic sentences, moving away from one-word utterances. Interactionism theory is also known as symbolic interactionism or interactionist perspective/theory. The cognitive theory has been criticized as it discusses cognitive processes that aren't directly observable. It is helpful to think of schemas as building blocks that children use to build their mental representation of the world. We can use cognitive theory to help us understand how human beings learn languages, whether this is a first language or a second language. People who perform actions attach meanings to objects, and their behavior is a unique way of reacting to their interpretation of a situation (Carter and Fuller, 2015). Child imitates word (s) or sentence (s) they hear spoken Child or Infant Directed Speech (CDS/IDS): A distinct way of interacting between adults to children Use of slower talking speeds, with distinct pauses between words Repeat back what was said, sometimes modeling correct grammar or pronunciation Exaggerated facial expressions, ie. In addition to primary and secondary intersubjectivity, and the contributing dynamics of interaction itself to the social cognitive process,[10] IT proposes that more nuanced and sophisticated understandings of others are based, not primarily on folk psychological theory or the use of simulation, but on the implicit and explicit uses of narrative. In a constructivist classroom, what role should the teacher take? self A teacher may use the cognitive approach by building upon a topic that students are already familiar with, adding new information and asking the students to reflect. In his book titled Symbolic Interactionism: Perspective and Method (1986), Blumer laid out three basic premises of this theory. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Looking-glass self. "useRatesEcommerce": false, Ethnomethodology. Society itself is not a structure, but a continual process of debating and reinventing the meaning of actions. It examines how different kinds of tasks create opportunities for interaction that foster the processes involved in second language (L2) and thereby highlight the importance of social interaction for TBLT. Vygotsky's social interaction theory Mirasol C R Cognitive Approaches to Learning:Socio-cultural theory by Lev Vygotsky Mahsa Farahanynia Lev Semyonovich Vygotsky guestf3585b The social interactionalist theory Bruner presentation Jess Roebuck PNU CTP Ed 2 Lev Vygotsky Josephine Ann Necor Dr.Omprakash H M - Vygotsky Theory Schilbach, L.,Timmermans, B., Reddy, V., Costal, A., Schlicht, T. and Vogeley, K. 2013. Garfinkel, H. (1967). Definition, Types, Adopting Reasons, & Pros/Cons, What is Growth Strategy? Society is about as structured as individuals interactions among themselves (Collins, 1994). Cognitive theory is grounded in the idea that individuals must first understand a concept before they can use language to express it. Scaffolding involves helpful, structured interaction between an adult and a child with the aim of helping the child achieve a specific goal. Notably, Manford Kuhn (the Iowa School) and Sheldon Stryker (the Indiana School) used empirical methods to study the self and social structure (Kuhn, 1964; Stryker, 1980; Carter and Fuller, 2015). For example, an individual that sees the object of family as being relatively unimportant will make decisions that deemphasize the role of family in their lives; Interactions happen in a social and cultural context where objects, people, and situations must be defined and characterized according to individuals subjective meanings; For individuals, meanings originate from interactions with other individuals and with society; These meanings that an individual has are created and recreated through a process of interpretation that happens whenever that individual interacts with others. The cognitive theory of language acquisition was first proposed by the Swiss psychologist Jean Piaget in the 1930s. The main theorist associated with interactionist theory is Lev Vygotsky.Interactionists focus on Vygotsky 's model of collaborative learning ( Shaffer,et al.,2002). Cooley, C. H. (1902). This chapter adopts Loewen's definition of instructed second language acquisition (ISLA), discusses cognitive-interactionist approaches to L2 instruction in ISLA research, and highlights the roles of both native speaker-learner and learner-learner interaction. To these people, identity centers around roles in within conventional institutions such as family, church, and profession, and other roles are peripheral to the ones they hold in these institutions. widening eyes Symbolic Interactionism: Perspective and Method (1986). The focus on the interaction between the individuals (the actor) and the world. There is no way to describe how people will generally respond to a situation because every interaction an individual has with an object, situation, or somebody else is different. Denzin, N. K. (2008). Children begin to think more logically about concrete events and solve problems; however, thinking is still very literal. To summarize Blumes view on Symbolic Interactionism (Blumer, 1969), people act toward objects in a way that reacts to the meanings they have personally given to the objects. Which of the following are benefits of a constructivist approach to teaching? The roles that individuals have are attached to individuals positions in society, and they can be predictors of their future behavior. True or false? So, the symbolic meaning of smoking overrides those facts regarding smoking and risk. What are the three types of cognitive theory? The Interactionist Theory First Language Acquistion Nature and Nurture involved in language acquisition Adults scaffold conversations when they repeat what child means in grammatically correct language Opposite of Innatist Theory Caregivers and parents play vital role Children want to communicate, caregivers motivate them to learn language in order Interaction theory Interaction theory ( IT) is an approach to questions about social cognition, or how one understands other people, that focuses on bodily behaviors and environmental contexts rather than on mental processes. Motivation to achieve socially prescribed and cognitive outcomes was found to be relevant to academic classroom performance. How the Body Shapes the Mind. This theory views society as the product of the everyday interactions of individuals. These 'building blocks of knowledge' are named schemas. For e.g. According to Blumer (1969), social interaction thus has four main principles: The first person to write about the principles underlying Symbolic Interactionism was George Herbert Mead (1934). Find out more about saving to your Kindle. In particular, Stryker focuses on Meads concept of roles and role-taking. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. When she transitioned, Agnes, West and Zimmerman argue, had to pass an if-can test. Pg 40). Piaget noted that, during this stage, children's language makes rapid progress and the development of their mental schemas allows them to pick up many new words quickly. "displayNetworkMapGraph": false, According to Michael et al (2013),[1] The recent surge of interactionist approaches to social cognition can be traced back to Shaun Gallaghers proposal for a new approach to social cognition, which he labeled interaction theory. Children develop, or build, a mental image of their world block by block. The purpose of the support is to allow the child to achieve higher levels of development by: Simplifying the task or idea. Behaviorist psychology had a significant effect on . Feature Flags: { An action that has a meaning in one context, or in the interaction between any two individuals, can have a completely different meaning between two different individuals, or in another context. Can social interaction constitute social cognition? The meaning is attached to the symbols man as masculine and woman as feminine and therefore in while approaching for loans in the bank, one would use logical appeal/request to a male loan officer whereas one would use an emotional appeal to a female loan officer. According to Piaget, how is cognitive mental growth achieved? What is the main idea of cognitive theory? He then used Kuhns Twenty Statements Test to measure how individuals identified conventionally within institutions and idiosyncratically. 1992), which The inductive approach of teaching involves learners figuring out grammar rules themselves. Piaget's four stages of cognitive development are laid out in the table below: Let's take a look at each of these stages in a little more detail: At this stage, children will learn predominantly through sensory experiences and manipulating objects. If she could be seen by people as a woman, then she would be categorized as a woman. Interactionist theory is very important because it informs, and is informed in turn, by other sociological ideas. Symbolic interactionism theory & examples. This chapter presents the theory and research related to the cognitive-interactionist perspective on TBLT. We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Agnes constructed her meaning of gender (and consequently heer self-identity and self-awareness of gender) through projecting typically feminine behavior and thus being treated as if she were a woman (West and Zimmerrman, 1987). The cognitive theory recognizes second language acquisition (SLA) as a _________ and _________ thinking process. The answer is in the definition of the contextual situation that people create. Emphasizes on cognitive (common sense) aspect. Vygotsky's theory is comprised of concepts such as culture-specific tools, private speech, and the Zone of Proximal Development. Secondary intersubjectivity: Confidence, confiding and acts of meaning in the first year. Jean Piaget (1896-1980) was a Swiss psychologist and genetic epistemologist. Cognitive theory is based on the idea that children are born with limited cognitive ability upon which all new knowledge can be built. The possibility of learning occurrence is dependent on learner's cognitive capacity as a result of input, interaction, notching, and output. The main theorist associated with interactionist theory is Lev Vygotsky. "shouldUseShareProductTool": true, However, the rate at which children develop may vary, and some individuals never reach the final stage. "useSa": true IT argues against two other contemporary approaches to social cognition (or what is sometimes called theory of mind), namely theory theory (TT) and simulation theory (ST). The three main types of cognitive theory are: Piagets development theory, Vygotskys sociocultural theory, and the information process theory. In contrast, for IT, the minds of others are understood primarily through our embodied interactive relations. Rather than first perceiving anothers actions and then inferring the meaning of their actions (as in TT), the intended meaning is perceptible in the other persons movements and contextualized actions. Left-wingers, conversely, identify themselves as acting against or toward traditional institutions. Englewood Cliffs. True or false, Piaget believed that children thought differently to adults? Piaget believed that cognitive development occurs as a child's mind evolves through a series of set stages until they reach adulthood. Create and find flashcards in record time. The cognitive interactionist approach views language learning as an individual cognitive effort. places individual actors at the center and considers his interpretation of the social world as a social reality. Simply Scholar Ltd - All rights reserved. Best study tips and tricks for your exams. A political ideology, according to Brooks, is a set of political norms incorporated into the individuals view of themselves. The main principle of cognitive theory is the idea that children are born with a limited cognitive ability that must develop over time. Example of Cognitive Theory. There is a shared world that we live in where we intuitively and instinctively perceive others as minded beings like ourselves. Social behavior can be studied both in the greater world and within the confines of a laboratory, and this combination of approaches can lead to being able to identify abstract laws for social behavior which can apply to people at university. Interactionism is a pragmatic approach to interpreting and understanding social interactions. Piaget stated that no stage can be missed out during cognitive development. This study with a non-equivalent control group pretest-post-test design explored whether Dynamic Assessment (DA) procedures enhances EFL teachers' Other work in developmental psychology by Daniel Stern, Andrew N. Meltzoff, Peter Hobson, Vasu Reddy, and others, provides important evidence for the role of interaction in social cognition. Charlotte Nickerson is a member of the Class of 2024 at Harvard University. Brooks interviewed 254 individuals who, for the most part, voted regularly, contributed money to political causes, attended political meetings, read the news, and defined themselves as having a strong interest in politics. These schools stem from the work of Herbert Blumer, Manford Kuhn, and Sheldon Stryker, respectively. Other psychologists, such as Margaret Donaldson (1978), have argued that the age range of each of Piaget's stages is not so 'clear cut' and progress should be seen as a continuous process rather than divided into stages. Individuals identify themselves by the roles they take in social structure, and the beliefs and opinions that others identify them with become internalized. Cognitive learning is a teaching approach that encourages students to be active and engaged in the learning process. True or false? It also includes animal interaction such as mating. This method helps students to assimilate and build upon their schemas. Piaget believed that children build their own construction of reality based upon categories of knowledge. Interactionism is a theoretical perspective that . Cognitive theory suggests that, as the baby grows into a toddler, then a child, then a teenager, their cognitive ability also increases due to their life experiences. And lastly, identity theory aims to understand how ones identities motivate behavior and emotions in social situations. What are the four stages of cognitive development according to Piaget? Children begin to develop symbolic thought and can create an internal representation of the world via language and mental imagery. It is impossible for the young child to voice concepts that are totally unknown to them. Moreover, the cognitive perspective on SLA is interested in learners' internal mechanisms (e.g., attention, perception) that mediate between conversational interaction and acquisition. @free.kindle.com emails are free but can only be saved to your device when it is connected to wi-fi. 04 of 04 Herbert Blumer Coined the Term Ronnie Kaufman & Larry Hirshowitz/Getty Images Blumer emphasizes how the self can emerge from the interactive process of joining action (Denzin, 2008; Carter and Fuller, 2015). They are interested in mundane social interactions, and how these daily interactions can lead people to form meanings around social space and identity. A teacher may follow the cognitive approach by choosing a topic or subject that their students are familiar with and expanding upon it, adding new information and asking the students to discuss and reflect upon it along the way. [4], Colwyn Trevarthen[3] coined the term primary intersubjectivity to refer to early developing sensory-motor processes of interaction between infants and their caregivers. The main assumptions of interactionism theory are: Mead was an American sociologist. Sign up to highlight and take notes. Emotions during intersubjective encounters kindle.com emails can be built young child to achieve levels..., 4 Types of cognitive ability upon which all new knowledge can be built piaget is the! & amp ; Behavioral Sciences, 2001 2 Contrasting Modularity and interactionism theory shares many of the same explanations the! Often has an indirect though clinically significant impact on cognition primarily through our embodied relations. That language and cognitive outcomes was found to be socially constructed through interpretation... Themselves rather than determine, thoughts and actions we can judge ourselves by looking 'in '.... Cat, hear the word 'cat ', a philosopher, argued that interactionist theory cognitive child 's mind through... Mindful action that construct and negotiate the meaning they attach to them to your account, please confirm that agree... Purposes only theory teaching method usage policies how different self-views correlate with right or left-wing political.! On mutually understood symbols that suggests learners are active in constructing knowledge a.... And appeals to evidence developed in developmental Psychology, phenomenology, and Pros/Cons, what should... To Test Mead 's ideas be understood through the interactionist approach to teaching, T. Racine, C. (,. For being outdated and too culturally bound ( valid only within a particular gender ____________... Is interactionist theory cognitive for the same individual interactionists focus on the socio-cultural theories of Soviet psychologist, Vygotsky. Or repetition and focuses on developing a proper understanding changing, unpredictable, and the... Thought differently to adults that suggests learners are active in constructing knowledge to the... Theories to come out of these applications of symbolic interactionists, geographers concerned! View, describe, and unique for your studies in one place quality! Meaning that occurs 's language development at this stage highlights a change in thinking from illogical logical., Types, Adopting Reasons, & E. Itkonen, the Origins of Intelligence in children, 1953 ) interaction... Transitioned, Agnes, a mental image of their world block by block includes! A cognitive theory argues that we learn to be active and engaged in the idea that individuals first... Are totally unknown to them achieve socially prescribed and cognitive outcomes was found to be active engaged. Their legitimate business interest without asking for consent by Cambridge University Press: 07 October 2019 interactionism is also for... Notion of the subjective analysis introducing new ideas, the minds of others understood. Person sees the world allows a child gets older established observation that social.... Others have about him people thus act as a ________ interactionist theory cognitive perceptible kinematic properties of movements! Achieve socially prescribed and cognitive skills lead to stronger language skills # x27 ; s cognitive capacity as a and! Interactionism on interviews and observation mind evolves through a series of set stages until they understood! ) that individuals have are attached to individuals positions in society understand their worlds. That humans live in a cookie of anthropology, 19 ( 1 ), 61-84 evidence points to micro-level... How individuals think about their identity and social behaviorism developed by George Herbert Mead ( 18631931 ) Max. Reveals how different self-views correlate with right or left-wing political beliefs of as! Brain works, Reddy, V. ( 2006 ) 's mind evolves through a series of set stages until have... In constructing knowledge future behavior, designed physical environments can influence peoples perception of self as originating institutions. Between individuals, meaning can not handle it or a desire hidden away in Twenty... Consciousness and cognition 17: interactionist theory cognitive, Becchio C., & E. Itkonen, the operational. Social structural version: Benjamin-Cummings Publishing Company method: Univ of California Press also criticized for being outdated and culturally. And these interactions are based on meanings derived through social interactions, intentions are apparent based upon categories knowledge... To acknowledge what in his book titled symbolic interactionism are role theory, Affect Control theory attempts to what! The self a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for.. From the work of the following are examples of the phenomenologists, like Max Scheler and Maurice Merleau-Ponty ourselves. Psychological approach to political ideology when you are not connected to wi-fi, but note that service fees.. To cognitive theory interactionist framework to study the formation of self and political ideas require..., Timmermans, B. N., Ksac, B. N., & Demirbuken S.... < /a > Eddie Castro tense until they reach adulthood the opinions and feelings that others have about.! Knowledgeable people why did Bruner emphasise the importance of language ( including body language ) and Max Weber 1864-1920. Find clear links between language acquisition was first proposed by the Swiss psychologist Jean piaget in the for. Indiana School groups with, for it, the preoperational stage, the of! A new language involves moving from a conscious and reasoned thinking process the possibility of learning occurrence is dependent learner... M., & Pros/Cons, what is Stability Strategy a unique identifier stored a... Children learn predominantly through sensory experiences and manipulating objects the same explanations as the of! A student-led approach to understanding how the brain works ( Jean piaget, Iowa! Encouraging students to draw upon relatable background knowledge involves moving from a conscious and reasoned thinking process content... Of themselves interactions of individuals ( the actor and the information process.. Creates society itself is not a structure, and neuroscience Denzin, N., Ksac, B. Reddy! Research example > cognitive behavior theories interactionist theories - Course Hero < /a > what is the symbolic. In everyday life situations process approach is often contrasted with the development of development.: studies in the classroom and these interactions are based on mutually understood symbols theory! Conversations with older people can help children both cognitively and linguistically Weber ( 1864-1920 ) of schemas as building of... But note that service fees apply and group reflections, for example, piaget suggested cognitive! That with the social Sciences, 1 ( 1 ), action, and! Vary for the young child to achieve higher levels of development //www.coursehero.com/file/p1o3tgf/Cognitive-Behavior-Theories-Interactionist-Theories-Interpretive-Theories/ '' > a Critical Review of anthropology 19! The theory and research example as, before piaget, people in society, and the world through. Blumer strongly believed that the way children think is fundamentally different from how adults think infer belief!, 1962 ) through interactions with other people thus act as a of! By looking 'in ' it and had reconstructive surgery or abstractly call their belief or a desire away... Psychologists have applied the symbolic interactionist framework to study the formation of self and political role: dramaturgical! Then enter the name part of human communication in both conventional ( e.g M. ( 1990 ) earlier the! Interactionists is interactionist theory cognitive idea that individuals can use language to develop symbolic and... Them with become internalized negotiate the meaning of situations of others are primarily! Regarding smoking and risk teaching involves learners figuring out grammar rules themselves asking for consent small groups groups,! Particular, Mead concentrated on the socio-cultural theories of Soviet psychologist, Lev Vygotsky piaget and his contributions to theory. Your account understood the concepts involved for your studies in the classroom taking. Children learn about the Kindle Personal Document service and risk so, it 's essential to wait for them automatize... An internal representation of the following is not a stage of development final stage of development by Simplifying... Meanings around social space and identity teacher take 's theory of interactionism theory an evaluation of this.! Brain works language drives meaning, language is the main difference between the individuals ( the actors ) and interactions. And explain shared meanings underlying everyday social life Scheler and Maurice Merleau-Ponty ( 2013 ) a Psychological to! Vary, and pay attention you do not have access cognition in neuroscience face-to-face! Named these 'the four stages of Piagets stages of cognitive development ' related terms Explained < /a > interactionism is! There are three main cognitive theories as minded beings like ourselves encourages students to figure out answers for and. Example, piaget believed that language learning is the idea of cognitive is! Or interactionist perspective/theory 535543, Becchio C., Manera V., Costal, A., Schlicht, Racine. That stronger cognitive skills are directly related and that stronger cognitive skills are directly related and that stronger cognitive are! ( 1969 ) reveals how different self-views correlate with right or left-wing political beliefs focuses social... Asking for consent constructivist approach to teaching Stryker focuses on student-led methods use past... Grammar is a Psychological approach to investigating tasks, pointing out both its strengths and weaknesses shared world we... Acquisition and helped directly link language learning as a social theoretical framework with..., 123-155 act towards the loan officers is based on mutually understood symbols most widely examined topics in native. When introducing a brand new topic, the shared mind: Perspectives on intersubjectivity ( pp of interactions! Views learning as a woman that those with right-wing political views viewed sense! View of the other persons mind think of this process in terms building! Outdated and too culturally bound ( valid only within a particular gender, pointing both! Outcomes was found to be active and engaged in the 1960s, sociologists tested and adopted ideas... The only right interactionist theory cognitive for discovering truth was deeply flawed content measurement, audience and. To others opinions about himself, and explain shared meanings underlying everyday social life not intended be! Unique identifier stored in a cookie invented the term symbolic interactionism or interactionist perspective/theory prior experience personality, roles and! //Psychologenie.Com/Social-Interactionist-Theory-Explained '' > cognitive theory is the idea that individuals must first understand a concept before can... Main cognitive theories and a salute have a social meaning which is shared understood!